Proposed Bylaws Amendments

This is a member initiated Bylaws amendment process.

The Bylaws may be amended per Article XV (see below) by request of "not less than 3% of the members".  A conservative estimate of the minimum number of member signatures required to initiate this amendment process is 500. 

I am proposing that the members join with me to petition for the amendment of the Bylaws of the American Academy of Actuaries so as to provide for the direct election of all directors and officers by the members (i.e. MAAAs). 

You may help initiate the process to amend the Academy Bylaws in one of three ways:

  • Download, sign, and return to me the Petition Form for 1 Signer.  Information on how to return is on the form. 
  • Download one or more copies of the Petition Form for 20 Signers and use it to collect signatures form Academy members you know who want to amend the Academy Bylaws so as to allow for the direct election of all directors and officers by the membership.  Then return the completed Petition forms to me as indicated on the form.
  • If attending either the Society of Actuaries Annual meeting (10/26 - 10/28/09) or the American Academy of Actuaries Annual meeting (10/26/09 Luncheon meeting in conjunction with the SOA meeting) in Boston, you may sign one of the many petition forms that will be in circulation there. 

    Look for me or one of many others who will be collecting signatures on petition forms to initiate this important Bylaws amendment.
Important Information
By signing a petition you will only be initiating a process that will allow you to vote in the future on specific language of a proposed Bylaws amendment.  These Bylaws amendments will be drafted so as to provide every member of the Academy with an opportunity to vote in a competitive election for directors and officers they feel will be good representatives for them and the profession - as is the current process for the CAS and SOA.

We will limit amendments to only those necessary to accomplish the purpose as outlined in the OUTLINE (see downloads section).  The OUTLINE is intended to provide you with a clear description of the Bylaws amendments we are proposing so you can determine whether or not you wish to participate in initiating this amendment process.

We welcome any comments or suggestions any member might have to improve what we have proposed in the OUTLINE.  Send to Reply@BakosEnterprises.com.  We will try to incorporate any suggestions that seem to be improvements and in keeping with the general principles of providing for the direct election of directors and officers by the members in a contested election.  However, for obvious reasons we cannot guarantee that we will be able to or can please everyone

You will see that the OUTLINE attempts to provide for a fair distribution of directors and officers among the various practice areas present in the U.S. actuarial profession.  

Again, your signature on a petition only initiates a voting process.  If you feel that the final proposed Bylaws amendments are not appropriate, you may vote against them in the election run by the Academy even though you signed a petition.

The Process
After allowing some time for comments or suggestions relative to the OUTLINE, we will begin drafting actual Bylaws amendment language.  When finished we will expose this to the membership for additional comment and suggestions and make any modifications as appropriate and in keeping with the general objective.  The Bylaws amendment will be accompanied by a document that will compare the proposed revisions to the current language and provide a discussion of the reasons for recommending the changes.

When we have final Bylaws amendment language and have, in hand, petitions with at least the minimum number of signatures required to initiate a Bylaws amendment, we will submit this material to the Academy Board with a request to initiate a Bylaws amendment process.

The Academy Board, per Article XV (see below), would be required to "specify a reasonable period of time" within which the proposed amendments will be transmitted to the members for a vote.  A 2/3rds affirmative vote (of those members voting) will be required to pass the amendments.  

Timing
As noted in Article XV, Bylaws amendments "become effective 10 days following the end of the voting period upon the affirmative vote of two-thirds of the members voting."  We anticipate that the election would be carried out electronically but the Academy may also choose to conduct it by mail as they currently do not have any electronic voting methods in place.

Our target is to have, with your help, Bylaws amendments in place such that the first election of all directors and officers directly by MAAAs may participate in will be held during the summer of 2010.  You will note that there are provisions in the OUTLINE that address a necessary transition and also anticipate a later implementation.


Article XV—Amendments

Administrative, editorial, and technical amendments to the Bylaws that do not involve questions of policy or affect the substantive rights of the Academy’s members may be made by a vote of two-thirds of the Directors present at a duly convened meeting of the Board. Otherwise, amendments to the Bylaws may be proposed either by a vote of two-thirds of the Directors present at a duly convened meeting of the Board or by written request of not less than 3 percent of the members. The Board shall specify a reasonable period of time within which the proposed amendment shall be transmitted by the Secretary-Treasurer to the members by mail, which includes electronic means, and the time for votes to be mailed by the members to the Secretary-Treasurer. Such proposed amendment shall be accompanied by an appropriate discussion of the issues, and it shall become effective 10 days following the end of the voting period upon the affirmative vote of two-thirds of the members voting.

Descriptions

A one page Diagram has been added to the Downloads which summarizes the effect of the Bylaws changes in the election process being proposed. 

This one page summary may make it easier to visualize the changes being proposed.


An  Outline of the changes to the Bylaws that are being proposed is provided as the second item in the download list to the left.

If you have any comments or suggestions please forward them to reply@BakosEnterprises.com.
The Outline will be used as the basis for drafting the actual amendment language.  Please see the complete description of the process to the left.


Academy Leadership Analysis I provides some examples of how the Academy leadership has exhibited a strained interpretation of the Academy Bylaws.